> Posted by Joshua Goldstein aka Mr. Provocative
In The New York Times last week was a story of loss and despair titled “1.5 Million Missing Black Men”. It stated: “One out of every six black men, who today should be between 25 and 54 years old, have disappeared from daily life.” Where are these men? What does this mean to the women in their communities? The answer to the first question is that they often die early or are living out much of their lives behind bars. And the answer to the second question is equally tragic and heartbreaking: In many ravaged communities, there are not enough men to be fathers and husbands. In our republic, this reality of the missing men is a profound challenge to our values, our democracy, and our future as a nation. I think there is a consensus on that.
So, you ask me: What does this terrible set of facts about an American tragedy have to do with microfinance and international development? In my opinion, an awful lot. As policy makers and practitioners, it often seems that men have disappeared from our “interventions” and work plans. Resources are focused on empowering poor women, who will work hard and take care of the children (half of whom are boys), while the men are scoundrels or losers who cannot be counted on when it comes to the family’s well-being. Why prioritize men in poverty reduction strategies? Why waste resources on this failed sex?
Does this sound harsh? I hope so. I have been to enough conferences around the world, from Skoll to the Microcredit Summit, where poor men are missing from the conversation. And there is no urgent action plan being developed to counter this. Why? The pariah sex is treated as forsaken and unredeemable. This affects the next generation, too. As the fathers are written off, so will the sons be if this paradigm is perpetuated.
I believe international development professionals need to take up the challenge to return men to their families to be productive co-breadwinners. Not to empower these missing men is to condemn the poor woman in their lives to have to do absolutely everything for their families, from making all the money to changing all the diapers. Is that right or fair? In the U.S. and Europe, it is taken for granted today that men should shoulder more of the burden of raising a family—not less—in addition to working full time! Women demand it. And men, to a great extent, have begun to comply. But when it comes to the “Global South” such expectations are not even part of the conversation.
In the U.S., as a response to the degraded and futile existence of too many African American boys and young men, the President has announced a bold new initiative called My Brother’s Keeper, “to help break down barriers, clear pathways to opportunity, and reverse troubling trends which show too many of our boys and young men of color slipping through the cracks in our society.”
In my view, we should launch a campaign beginning today to push international development professionals to do more to take the Global South’s “second sex” more seriously. Of course it is a challenging proposition! But hope for a better world is in ruins if half of humanity is written off from the get go.
Photo credit: Gates Foundation
Have you read?
Vulnerable Minorities: There’s an Elephant in This Room
Impact Study Needed: Do Microfinance Conferences Help the Poor?


Facebook
Twitter
2 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 17, 2015 at 8:02 am
Barbara Magnoni
While I agree with the need for gender inclusiveness in programs, which would do a better job of incorporating men into opportunities to improve productivity, education and health; men are by no means missing from international development interventions.
Boys and men are more likely to go to school or attend government sponsored technical training in many countries. Boys and men continue to receive the better end of a meager family meal in many countries. They are most likely to use roads, bridges and cell phones, thus benefiting from infrastructure development. Men continue to govern at all levels (national, municipal, community), making choices for their communities with limited inclusion of women. Men also typically earn more both in wage labor and in microenterprises, where we have consistently observed higher levels of sales and growth in male-run businesses (eg. http://www.microfinancegateway.org/sites/default/files/mfg-en-paper-a-business-to-call-her-own-identifying-analyzing-and-overcoming-constraints-to-womens-small-businesses-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean-apr-2010.pdf). In larger businesses (SMEs and even large enterprises) in developing countries, women play very small roles. However, women are often hired in the lowest paid and less secure jobs. In Peru, I have spoken to many women who are day laborers who say they are paid almost half what male day laborers are paid and they spend hours in the sun picking crops, while “stronger” men supervise. Maquila factories (large and small) throughout Latin America are largely employed by women. Without economic equity, women are even more limited than poor men from making their own choices and pursuing opportunities. And though women “run” households in many cases, men also make some very important family decisions, including on the number of children women will have. Additionally, male doctors intervene in women’s health choices, often excluding them from the decisions that most matter to their reproductive health. In India, we see very high levels of elective hysterectomies. In Latin America, C-Sections are common even in some of the lowest income communities.
Gender equity seeks to include women and an understanding of women’s specific constraints in development programs so that the exclusion that we have historically observed can be reversed. Some programs may do a poor job of this, and that should definitely be changed. But efforts to seek gender equity should not be thrown out in the name of “missing men.” Instead, it is important when considering gender equity to understand the constraints that women and men face and with a specific effort to include all genders into these interventions. But beware, including women may take more effort, and thus more money, programming and awareness building than including men. They may have less access to information, less time, less trust, and less education and may need to be “caught up” in some cases. So be patient please and have faith that an equitable world will be a better one for us all.
May 18, 2015 at 1:28 pm
Joshua Goldstein
Barbara, thank you for your thoughtful comments. I want to assure you that I am a life long supporter of gender equity. Couldn’t agree more that emphasizing the productive role men should play in supporting their families should never be at the expense of women. And I completely agree that men continue to have preferential treatment in many ways in many workplaces. Nevertheless, at least in my little corner of the international development world, poor men are often given up on. And I think that is wrong and not a status quo we should accept or learn to live with. It is also unfair to the women, who should not have all the economic burden of raising their families on their shoulders alone.