Gail Buyske, Advisory Committee, Microfinance Information Infrastructure Project
> Posted by Center Staff

Several weeks ago we learned that MFT has suspended its operations. Moody’s has discontinued its Social Performance Assessment Program. The MIX is trying to increase revenue through its MixGold program. Should we care about these developments? What are they telling us about the state of microfinance’s information infrastructure?
The Center for Financial Inclusion undertook an analysis of these issues to follow up on Elisabeth Rhyne’s provocative blog of March 11, 2014, in which she argued that the microfinance industry needs an “infrastructure fix.” Today’s blog summaries the key issues, which will be discussed at a stakeholder discussion in DC on April 14, followed by one at a later date in Europe.
Let’s start by thinking about why we should care about microfinance’s information infrastructure. Information and its natural outcome, transparency, have been guiding principles of the microfinance industry practically since its inception. These are not just feel-good concepts: they played a fundamental role in the development of microfinance. Information and transparency were critical in microfinance’s early days in enabling donors and investors to identify promising MFIs that they could support. Readily available information enabled MFIs to benchmark their performance and set goals to improve their performance. And we can never forget that a commitment to transparency is a pact between MFIs and their clients.
In these days when microfinance sometimes seems to be an old story, it’s easy to overlook the organizations that made this commitment to information and transparency a reality: the MIX, the microfinance ratings agencies, and MFT. It’s also easy to construct an argument that these organizations grew at least partly with donor funding, their original missions have been achieved, and it is up to “the market” to decide their future.
This takes us to the second question: what is the market telling us? Let’s look at some facts. Out of a universe of 2600 MFIs, 15 percent have both a 4+ diamond rating and have reported recent data to the MIX. Approximately 50 MFIs conduct ratings every year, 200 conduct ratings every 18-36 months and another 600 conduct them once in five years. MFT collected pricing data from 535 MFIs and recent data from 195 of them. One clear message is that the infrastructure is underutilized.
Does underutilization mean that the infrastructure has outlived its usefulness? Answering this question requires understanding a key dynamic: the information infrastructure is being “privatized.” Information and transparency are as important as ever, but they are moving out of the public information infrastructure. Large investors have developed in-house capacity to collect and analyze data, so they get their information directly from their investees. As a result, MFIs are under less pressure to report quickly to the MIX. Investors have also developed their ability to do their own due diligence and therefore do not rely on ratings.
How we interpret and respond to this dynamic will have an important impact on the future development of microfinance. These are some key questions to consider:
- What are the public good components of the microfinance information infrastructure and what would happen if “the market” did not support the infrastructure? This question is particularly relevant for standard-setting work such as the Progress out of Poverty Index and the Smart Campaign.
- Does being a member of the microfinance community imply a moral commitment to support its public goods? If so, how can we ensure that they are provided effectively and efficiently?
- To what degree does underutilization reflect privatization of the information infrastructure compared to other reasons why these tools are not being used to the maximum extent?
- What would it actually cost to ensure the viability of the information infrastructure?
We hope that you will join the stakeholder discussion on April 14 to share your views. Please contact Anne Hastings at for more information.
Image credit: Va. Dept. of Conservation
Have you read?


Facebook
Twitter
3 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 7, 2015 at 1:38 pm
Chuck Waterfield
I do share your concerns that the public infrastructure (and public transparency) is getting replaced by privatized, internal information collection that gives funders and networks the ability to make decisions without the MFI being obliged to share information transparently via MFT or MIX. The industry will have less and less transparent information unless funders and networks *insist* that MFIs they support be transparent, And I know of not a single one that is currently insisting. They ask MFIs to be transparent, but they accept “no” as an answer.
I do want to ask or clarify the figure you used for MFT. The article says MFT collected data on 135 MFIs. We actually received data from 532 MFIs, as you can find listed here:
http://www.mftransparency.org/microfinance-pricing/
It may be that your figure was filtering for “MFIs in the last x months” or “MFIs who have more than x clients”, but the 135 figure, without any explanation, seriously understates the number of MFIs who did voluntarily share their pricing data with MFT.
Chuck Waterfield
CEO, MFTransparency
April 8, 2015 at 11:14 pm
Chuck Waterfield
Thanks for making the correction in the MFT figures
April 14, 2015 at 4:39 pm
J. Urquizo
I think producing data is not enough. More in depth analysis of the other side (the users of data/information) should be done. How much market of users for specific type of data is out there? Who would use the data/information? , to do what? , with what frequency?
Two years ago, I did a feasibility study to perform a multi-countrry survey, some takeaways were for example that the effective interest in using information from data provider’s changes depending on how well, the organizations, can apply to their own objectives what the information/data reveals. Financial regulators and international organizations are likely to benefit the most from aggregated studies because it gathers information at national level, however regulators had their own sources of data from their research departments that gauge specific issues of they were working on. In the same way, the interest of local networks of MFIs was focused on getting data/information to support their negotiations with regulators. Practitioners were more interested in data that shows new business opportunities.
So looking closer to the perspective of the potential users of information/data is one improvement we should look for.