> Posted by Elisabeth Rhyne, Managing Director, CFI
I was recently asked to give a talk at the University of Pennsylvania’s 8th (!) annual Microfinance Conference. This year’s theme, “Microfinance Beyond Its Roots” set me in search of ways in which the microfinance industry is moving into areas beyond its original microcredit core. Of course, this process has been going on for a long time, and so there are many topics to choose from.
I decided to look at health care, partly because, as every staff member of a microfinance institution knows, health setbacks are one of the most frequent sources of repayment problems among low income clients. As they learned about the health vulnerabilities of their clients, microfinance organizations began to invest in experiments, bringing their businesslike approach to bear on a challenge that is often dealt with in heavily subsidized, non-market ways. Today, many of these programs have matured and grown, even as new ideas are being tested.
I looked among the organizations belonging to the Microfinance CEO Working Group, and I found that nearly all have something exciting going on in health care. Approaches include some combination of direct health care service provision, health insurance coverage, and education. Many are using technology as a means of reaching people at scale and low cost.
The meetings associated with group lending provide a convenient and cost-effective platform for health services, and adding a health component to group microcredit is probably the earliest and most widespread model. Health education was perhaps the starting point, as pioneered by Freedom from Hunger and also implemented by Opportunity International. Today the services often reach farther (while health education continues to be important). ProMujer, for example, directly employs nurses and other health practitioners to staff fixed and mobile clinics available to ProMujer members. They focus on maternal and reproductive health, as well as screening for the chronic diseases that are increasingly major health issues in Latin America. Hundreds of thousands of women get access to health care through ProMujer’s efforts.
Health insurance is another area of important advances. As one of many examples, Women’s World Banking, working with Microfund for Women in Jordan and Zurich Financial Services, developed a hospital insurance program, Caregiver, that pays hospital fees and a share of lost income when a client is hospitalized. I find it revealing that Caregiver does not try to cover every health need. It focuses on a specific range of services prioritized in a particular market – the costs associated with hospitalization. From looking at all these initiatives, I conclude that selecting a limited range of high-priority needs to address is part of what enables programs to cover their costs and thus be scalable and sustainable.
Stepping beyond microfinance clients, Opportunity International, together with local insurer ELAC and Airtel mobile operator, provides life and health insurance free to Airtel subscribers in Ghana. This program applies what Opportunity has learned about microinsurance since it created MicroEnsure a decade ago, to benefit all Airtel users.
Grameen Foundation is also using mobile technology as a health care tool. Here’s an elegant application of its MOTECH platform, which connects directly from providers to patients: One of the challenges of chronic disease treatment is making sure patients take their medication on schedule. For HIV positive patients in India, MOTECH sends an automated phone message every morning asking, “Have you taken your medicine this morning? Press 1 for yes, 2 for no.” If the patient answers no (or doesn’t respond), MOTECH calls again in half an hour. No response triggers escalating interventions, including contact from the health care provider. These messages increase compliance and keep patients healthy.
Accion’s Venture Lab is also investing in mobile technology as a health care tool, through Mera Doctor, in India, which offers subscribers 24/7 access to a phone consultation with a doctor, together with health insurance and discounts on drugs.
I’d like to know more about all of these efforts – like how many people they are reaching, how sustainable they are, and what the program designers have found to be key success factors. I think the numbers may be surprisingly large. Freedom from Hunger, for example, is working with about 25 MFI partners around the world reaching a combined total of over 2.6 million women with multiple-benefit health packages.
What I am fairly certain about is that these programs all benefit from their connection to microfinance. In some cases, the connection is direct: you must be a microfinance client to receive the services. In others, however, the connection is indirect: in the knowledge the microfinance organizations have gained about low income clients and in their experience building sustainable social business models.
Image credit: ProMujer
Have you read?
Balancing Client Value and the Business Case in Kenyan Health Microinsurance
Microinsurance Gets Three Wishes
Microfinance CEOs Make Six Major Commitments at 2013 Partnerships Against Poverty Summit


Facebook
Twitter
3 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 9, 2014 at 1:50 pm
Getaneh Gobezie
Hello Elisabeth and all
I am happy to read this … I strongly believe that no less important than creating the access to finance to the poor, using microfinance (especially the group-lending modality) as a ‘platform’ to other intervention would do a great service to the poor and wider community. …
I would like to bring to your attention a similar programme in Uganda supported by Oxfam-Novib, using microfinance forums to promote enterprise development as well as empowerment of women and gender equality. Results are quite impressive….
An article evaluating this, titled:
”Promoting Empowerment of Women and Gender Equality through Integrated Microfinance, Value-chain Support and Gender Capacity Building — The Case of Bukonzo Joint Cooperative Microfinance Service Ltd (Uganda)”
is posted at CGAP/Microfinancegateway.org and can be accessed from the link:
http://www.microfinancegateway.org/p/site/m/template.rc/1.9.64362/
I can also send the doc by e-mail. Please contact at:
Thanks and regards
Getaneh Gobezie
April 15, 2014 at 8:00 pm
Steve Hollingworth
Thanks Beth for highlighting the important link between microfinance and health protection.
I have been pretty outspoken about the need for the microfinance industry to refocus on its core mission; creating sustainable approaches that impact the lives of poor clients. Adding health is one very tangible way we can do that.
Beyond being the right thing to do, there is a business case that supports this approach. The fact is, it’s not expensive. Our cost analyses show costs range from US$.27 to $1 per family (per year) for an MFI to offer health -protection services to its clients. Second, we know that health shocks are the leading factor driving loan defaults and that they play a central role in driving the vulnerable into poverty (or back into poverty). Third, it builds demand for special health-oriented financial services such as health savings accounts and health loans. Even for those interested solely in financial returns, we think this is an investment worth making.
In 2006, Freedom from Hunger launched its Microfinance and Health Protection (MAHP) initiative as a four-and-a-half-year pilot project, funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. That pilot allowed us to work with five MFIs in five countries to develop and offer a range of health-protection services to improve the health and financial stability of their clients. This was new territory at the time, but we were convinced of the potential. What we have learned over the past eight years has confirmed the value of this approach, both for scale and deeper poverty alleviation impacts that we would all like to see.
In 2012, Freedom from Hunger partnered with the Microcredit Summit Campaign to launch the Health and Microfinance Alliance to promote the expanded uptake of integrated health and financial services. The results of the Gates’ pilot exceeded all of our expectations and, as a result, today we are reaching more than 2.6 million people in ten countries with 34 partner organizations.
We recognize that the needs in Ecuador and India are different from those in Mali or the Philippines. Thus, we work with local partners who share our commitment to the poor. We design, develop and deliver contextually appropriate, low-cost, effective and sustainable health-protection packages that typically include a mix of health education, health financing (i.e., health loans, savings accounts and micro-insurance), linkages to healthcare providers and access to health products.
It’s an exciting time. Technology is an important enabler in this area. We are currently piloting new innovations for health financing (including mobile- and card-payment systems in partnership with Visa) and using telemedicine to reach more rural clients with access to high-quality specialty care.
In 2010, InterAction awarded Freedom from Hunger its Best Practices and Innovations Award for our groundbreaking work in this area. In 2011, the Global Health Council awarded Freedom from Hunger its Best Practices in Global Health Award for effectively demonstrating the link between health, poverty and development.
There’s plenty to be done and we hope that others will join us. For those of us who remain committed to the original mission, this is a “no-brainer.”
April 23, 2014 at 1:20 pm
John Tippett
Elisabeth, thanks for highlighting some of the existing work and potential for integrating microfinance with health services. The clients we all serve are multi-faceted, so our approaches to sustainably addressing their challenges must be multi-faceted as well. We in the health domain have much to integrate, learn, and apply from the world of microfinance.
For anyone interested in more information about the health service for HIV patients you mentioned, a video highlighting it is available at http://youtu.be/RXcpC_kXqZo. For more information about Grameen Foundation’s health technologies, see http://motechsuite.org.
John Tippett
Director of Mobile Health Innovations
Grameen Foundation