> Posted by Center Staff
In Bangladesh, the ugly events of the last few months have reached a climax, and everyone in the microfinance industry would do well to wake up — and speak up.
What’s afoot? As the Financial Times puts it: “After publicly denouncing the founder of Grameen Bank for corruption and of ‘sucking the blood’ of the poor, Dhaka has limply resorted to a legal technicality to remove the Nobel Prize winner from the board of the microfinance institution.”
What’s at stake? In the words of Sam Daley-Harris, the director of the Microcredit Summit Campaign, this is “the latest move in a campaign to persecute Prof. Yunus and undermine the independence of Grameen Bank.” And because Grameen has yet to comply with Dhaka’s dictates, as the Financial Times observes, the deadlock resulting from this “political score-settling” can hurt only “both the bank and the wider microfinance industry.”
There are signs that Dhaka’s scorched-earth assault is already causing a closing of ranks in the industry, even where professionals have in the past been divided by debates. One good example appears on the Philanthrocapitalism blog, where Matt Bishop and his co-authors state that “[T]hough we have issues with Mr Yunus’s attacks on for-profit microfinance, we stand shoulder-to-shoulder with him in opposing this politically-motivated attack.”
We can only echo this statement. At this critical moment for microfinance, attacks of this type on someone of Dr. Yunus’ stature are attacks on us all. To the extent possible, we have to have his back.


Facebook
Twitter
7 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 3, 2011 at 3:04 pm
Andrew Sprung
It’s astounding that the Bangladeshi government does not even attempt to cloak its hostility in even a marginally credible pretext. Grameen’s interest rates are too high? They’re among the lowest in the industry. A slanted documentary charged wrongdoing? The allegedly wronged Norwegian government found none. Finally, the Bank of Bangladesh is shocked, shocked to discover that Mr. Yunus is over 60 years old (he’s 70).
The wrong is not just to Mr. Yunus. The Grameen Bank he found is a flagship institution for the microfinance industry. An arbitrary change of management could be a blow it its viability — and so to the well-being of its millions of clients. That is the real shame.
March 4, 2011 at 4:09 pm
Center for Financial Inclusion
Dear Mr. Sprung,
Thank you for reading and contributing your thoughts. We appreciate it, and we hope you’ll visit this blog again to learn more about the attack on Dr. Yunus and the industry response.
Best regards,
Center Staff
March 4, 2011 at 2:55 am
Peter Burgess
I am pretty disgusted at political leadership in general, but the situation in Bangladesh is bad news and worth paying attention to. If political performance was anything like as good as the Muhammad Yunus and Grameen performance, the world would be a much better place. I am about the same age as Dr. Yunus, and the age issue is coming up. As I get older I am realizing that issues that are arising are many times because younger people do not have a good history of experience … and in some ways worse than it used to be because of so much silo specialization and reliance on academic research rather than operational experience. Anyway … wish Dr. Yunus well.
March 4, 2011 at 4:13 pm
Center for Financial Inclusion
Dear Mr. Burgess,
Your point is well taken and we appreciate that you took the time to share your perspective. We intend to keep careful track of Dr. Yunus’ case as it develops. There is no way that this appalling situation can receive too much scrutiny, and much remains to be done by the microfinance community to respond.
Best regards,
Center Staff
March 7, 2011 at 9:39 pm
Cristian Shoemaker
While noting with respect the achievements of Dr. Yunus and Grameen, there is a lesson here. Mixing one’s interest in participating in politics, while actively serving in a leadership role for a financial institution, especially one with 8 million clients, is unwise. Although in an ideal world that would not be the case, it is in the world we live in. Unfortunately it is difficult to reach for honey and not get stung.
March 8, 2011 at 3:54 pm
Center for Financial Inclusion
Dear Mr. Shoemaker,
Thank you for sharing your perspective, and thank you for reading. More on Dr. Yunus’ case will be appearing on this blog soon.
Best regards,
Center Staff
June 9, 2011 at 9:32 am
Yunus, Grameen & Bangladesh: What Are the Facts? «
[…] Who Has Muhammad Yunus’ Back? […]